Reservation
+1 614-754-1660
Visit Us
958 Demorest Rd, Columbus, OH 43204, United States
Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Pizza 1 topping
Bottle of Water
Pizza of the month (chicken, bacon, ranch.) Jan/25
Chicken melody
About
Westside Slice
Welcome to Westside Slice, a hidden culinary gem located at 958 Demorest Rd, Columbus, OH. If you're searching for authentic, mouth-watering pizza, delicious subs, and fresh salads, you need to make a stop here. The inviting atmosphere and exemplary service will captivate you from the moment you walk in.
At Westside Slice, the star of the menu is undeniably their pizza. Priced reasonably, their one-topping pizza starts at just $14.99, with an array of additional toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and jalapeños available for only $1.25 each. Their specialty pies, such as the Meat Lovers Pizza and the mouthwatering Westside Special – loaded with everything from crispy pepperoni to savory sausage – are testament to their commitment to deliciousness.
The crust deserves special mention: customers rave about its perfect balance of crispiness on the edge and a tender base—creating an ideal bite every time. Reviewers like Andrea Coyne highlight the thin yet wonderfully crisp crust that pairs beautifully with their rich and zesty tomato sauce. “Great flavor for both and very reasonably priced,” Andrea notes, showcasing the value found at Westside Slice.
The quirks of Westside Slice extend beyond just pizza. As Mary Broskey shares, the cheesy bread, described as a calzone, is a must-try. Diners especially love that they can catch delightful moments like early happy hours for added savings. The friendly staff, including owner Danny, ensures a personal touch, making each visitor feel at home. Danny often engages with customers, providing camaraderie and even entertainment with arcade games for kids, as mentioned in glowing customer reviews.
If you’re seeking comfort food, don’t overlook their subs and delectable chicken wings—raved about by loyal patrons and available exclusively on certain days. The wings are noted for their fall-off-the-bone tenderness, further establishing Westside Slice as a local favorite. Patrons like Chris Fisher found their wings even surpassing popular local chains, demonstrating Westside's unique edge.
In conclusion, if you find yourself in Columbus, Ohio, Westside Slice should definitely be at the top of your list. With a combination of top-notch pizza, exceptional customer service, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere, it promises a satisfying dining experience. We’re eager to visit again and dive into more of their enticing offerings—from the classic pies to those intriguing new flavors like the Chicken Melody pizza. Your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Hidden gem! Pizza crust was thin and just crisp on the edges. Cheesy bread includes homemade sauce and has the perfect spice on top. Great flavor for both and very reasonably priced. Danny the owner came out to greet us and even turned on the arcade games for our son to play while we waited for our order. If you're in Columbus, Ohio, def stop here! ”
“ I grew up on the west side. I've had favorites for years (and still do for nostalgic reasons) but I can honestly say this is hands down the best pizza on the west side and the best Ohio style pie I've had in Columbus. The crust is a perfect combination of crispy and tender and the sauce is thick and rich. They are generous with the toppings and it's a really, really nice pie. Bonus points for the super friendly service. I slept on this place for way too long, it's our new go to. ”
“ Must try!. You won't regret it. Very good pizza. Very good amount of toppings and very tasty pizza, good crust and crunch. We were very happy with our order. Will be back. We ordered a personal and a Hawaiian. ”
“ Located on Demorest Rd by the Briggs traffic light. It was my first time here, & won't be my last! Everyone I spoke with was very friendly. Turned out I came during Happy Hour! (I arrived Monday at 5 pm.) I saved 5 off of my pizza! I ordered cheesy bread which was like a stuffed calzone & a pepperoni pizza. The crust is a crispy thin crust. The sauce is a zesty tomato. The toppings were cooked to perfection. Everything was super delicious & I recommend everyone to try it! I will be returning! I am excited to try other items on the menu! UPDATE: I have been coming here every Thursday since my first time. I LOVE this place. Everything I've tried is delicious! The added photos are of: The Italian Sub, The Westside Special, & new Chicken Wings! Only available on Thursday, if you love fall-of-the-bone wings, this is a must-try! Thanks, Westside Slice, you have truly outdone yourselves! See ya next Thursday! You know I'm getting the chicken! NEW: Chicken Melody! White sauce pizza with chicken breast, spinach, sundried tomatoes & feta cheese, the best pizza I've ever had! ”
“ I saw an article about this place in a Columbus magazine last year. My family and I were in the area on our way home and figured that we would try it out. It has to the best pizza in Columbus and is definitely a hidden gem. The pizza crust is hand made and is a unique mix of thin, airy, light, and crispy. I have always enjoyed a good crust with the pockets of air, so this really hit the spot. We also tried some of their wings, and they were excellent. I felt that they were a better version of Roosters wings. We unfortunately didn’t leave room for dessert but will be trying their cookies and ice cream next time! ”
“ Yooo, dynamite pizza! Loved visiting this spot. The fellas that run it are real friendly and hospitable. You can tell they're passionate in their craft. Really appreciate the option of having beef pepperoni, hard finding that for non pork eaters. Was very delicious, the crispiness of the crust and pepperoni was perfect. The sauce was really good too, more on sweeter side which I like. The pepperoni had a great spice to it, next time will add mushrooms after reading since other reviews. We also ordered a house salad, which was fresh and no soggy/browned lettuce, and plenty of cheese and dressing as well as a cookie pizza. Definitely eat that cookie fresh as possible, it hardens up quite quickly. I've tried around 6 different non franchise pizza spots here in Columbus since moving here in early 2023, would be confident to say it's my favorite pizza here. I can see myself ordering a pizza for the wife and I every 2-3 weeks. They're building up this shop and putting in arcade machines for it's patrons. It's tucked away in a corner plaza where you wouldn't expect this treasure, which is usually how it goes huh? ”
“ Tonight was our first time trying westside slice. Did not disappoint and definitely lived up to the reviews I've been seeing . He told me he's got the best wings in town and according to my boyfriend, he is correct. My pizza was amazing. I love a good crust and the type of mushrooms and the cut of the onions *chefs kiss* . 10/10 we will for sure be back. Thanks for a quick easy yummy dinner tonight . ”
“ Absolutely delicious! We ordered pizza for delivery- white chicken, a sausage and onion, and cheesy bread. Everything was so good and flavorful and fresh. This is going to be our new go-to for pizza. ”